Athos does not scowl at the mention of the Cardinal's sins, but it is a close thing. He holds little affection or respect for the man, but there are times when even the Cardinal can surprise him with how far he takes his actions. "I am sorry you had to take his life, but glad that you found retribution." Athos knows that both things can weigh heavily upon a man. If he were Aramis or Porthos, perhaps he might ask if d'Artagnan is all right.

"Drink," he says instead. "It sounds as if you need it."